Skip to main content
Lien Resolution Processes

5 Common Mistakes to Avoid in Medicare Lien Resolution

By January 6, 2025January 28th, 2025No Comments

Medicare lien resolution is a critical aspect of personal injury settlements involving Medicare beneficiaries. Failing to properly address Medicare liens can lead to significant legal and financial consequences for both attorneys and their clients. At LitPRO, we’ve seen firsthand the pitfalls that can arise when handling Medicare liens. Here are five common mistakes to avoid in Medicare lien resolution before settlement:

Relying on Conditional Payment Letters

One of the most frequent errors in Medicare lien resolution is relying on Conditional Payment Letters (CPLs) as final figures. CPLs are preliminary estimates and do not represent the final amount owed to Medicare. Only a Final Demand Letter from Medicare confirms the actual amount due and is legally binding.

Attorneys who base their settlements on CPLs risk significant shortfalls and potential legal issues. A notable example occurred in 2019 when a Maryland law firm settled a claim based on incorrect figures in a CPL, leading to complications and potential liability.

To avoid this mistake:

  • Always treat CPLs as preliminary information
  • Wait for the Final Demand Letter before finalizing settlement amounts
  • Educate clients about the difference between CPLs and Final Demand Letters

Neglecting Early Lien Identification

Another common error is failing to identify potential Medicare liens early in the case. Waiting until settlement negotiations are underway to address liens can lead to delays, complications, and potential breakdown of settlement agreements.

To mitigate this risk:

  • Identify Medicare beneficiaries at the outset of the case
  • Open lines of communication with Medicare early
  • Provide detailed documentation to support your case

Early identification allows for more accurate settlement planning and helps prevent last-minute surprises that could derail negotiations.

Improper Resolution Channels

Using incorrect methods to resolve conditional payments can have severe repercussions. Some attorneys mistakenly attempt to resolve Medicare liens through state court proceedings instead of following the required administrative processes.

A cautionary tale comes from a Texas case where an attorney sought a state court ruling to reduce the amount owed to Medicare. This approach proved ineffective, and the attorney faced legal action from the government for failure to properly reimburse Medicare.

To avoid this mistake:

  • Familiarize yourself with Medicare’s prescribed administrative processes
  • Use appropriate channels for appeals or compromise/waiver requests
  • Consider working with specialized lien resolution experts who understand these processes

Inaccurate Reporting of Date of Injury

A frequent error in Medicare lien resolution is confusing the date of diagnosis with the date of injury when reporting to Medicare. This mistake can lead to inaccurate lien calculations and potential compliance issues.

For cases involving ingestion, implantation, or exposure, the key date that should be reported to Medicare is the first date of exposure, ingestion, or implantation. This is crucial because Medicare needs to determine when the claimant was first at risk or affected by the event, which triggers their medical coverage responsibility.

To ensure accuracy:

  • Clearly distinguish between the date of injury and date of diagnosis
  • For ingestion cases, report the date the claimant first ingested the harmful substance
  • In implantation cases, use the date the implant was initially placed
  • For exposure cases, document the first date of exposure to the harmful substance

Failing to Specify Lien Types and Responsibilities in Settlement Agreements

Many settlement agreements use broad language requiring the resolution of “any and all liens” without specifying the types of liens or assigning clear responsibilities for lien resolution tasks. This lack of specificity can lead to confusion, delays, and potential disputes after settlement.

To avoid this pitfall:

  • Clearly specify which types of liens require resolution (e.g., Medicare Parts A & B, Parts C & D, private healthcare liens)
  • Explicitly state which party is responsible for various lien resolution tasks (identification, disclosure, certification, document production, etc.)
  • If working with a lien resolution administrator, include provisions that allow for lien “holdbacks” and flexible payment procedures

Additionally, be cautious about including overly specific requirements for proof of lien satisfaction. Government agencies with statutory recovery rights, like Medicare, do not typically provide formal releases to all parties upon lien satisfaction. Instead, settlement agreements should require reasonable documentation evidencing satisfaction rather than specific releases that may not be industry standard.

Medicare Lien Resolution Reminders

Navigating Medicare lien resolution can be complex and fraught with potential pitfalls. By avoiding these common mistakes, attorneys can protect their clients and themselves from unnecessary complications and legal risks. Remember:

  1. Don’t rely solely on Conditional Payment Letters
  2. Identify potential liens early in the case
  3. Use proper administrative channels for lien resolution
  4. Accurately report the date of injury
  5. Be specific about lien types and responsibilities in settlement agreements

Effective Medicare lien resolution requires diligence, attention to detail, and a thorough understanding of Medicare’s requirements and processes. By implementing these best practices, you can streamline the lien resolution process and achieve better outcomes for your clients.

How LitPRO Can Help with Medicare Lien Resolutions

At LitPRO, we specialize in navigating the complexities of Medicare lien resolution and other healthcare liens. Our team of experts can help you avoid these common mistakes and ensure smooth, compliant lien resolution for your cases. Don’t let Medicare lien issues derail your settlements or expose you to potential liability. Contact LitPRO today to learn how our expertise can streamline your lien resolution process, ensure compliance, and maximize recoveries for your clients. Let us be your partner in achieving optimal outcomes in these high-stakes cases. Reach out now to discover how LitPRO can enhance your lien resolution strategy and protect your firm’s interests.